By Mathew Carr and Gemini
Released around 02:00 AM local time on Sunday, November 22 (23:00 GMT Saturday) into a second day of overtime in Antalya, the COP31 Presidency’s condensed final package—led by Türkiye’s Murat Kurum and Australia’s Chris Bowen—strips the main cover decision down to 10 pages (from 18 pages and 144 paragraphs in the November 16 draft).
Delegations were given until 03:00 GMT (06:00 AM local time) to lodge objections ahead of a 06:00 GMT (09:00 AM local time) closing plenary. PillarWhat’s in the Final TextKey Shift / Flashpoint Fossil FuelsCompletely omitted.
No mention of “fossil fuels” or a phase-out/transition away.Both the COP28 Dubai transition text and a stronger phase-out option were cut, sparking pushback from the EU, SIDS, and Latin American states.
Electrification (“35-by-35”)Retains the global ambition to raise electricity’s share of final energy consumption to 35% by 2035 (up from ~23%).Does not mandate that the new electricity be renewable and lacks binding finance commitments. Carbon Capture (CCUS)Adds a collective goal to deploy gigatonne-scale CCUS by 2035.
Major concession to fossil-fuel producers and heavy industry; critics warn it gives political cover to keep producing oil and gas. Adaptation FinanceCalls for scaled-up resources and easier grant/concessional access, without a dollar figure or baseline year.Drops earlier draft language quantifying the tripling of adaptation finance at $120 billion/year by 2035. Loss & DamageUrges stronger coordination and predictable funding for the Loss and Damage Fund.Strips out specific funding-gap numbers that appeared in the November 19 draft. Post-Antalya TrackLaunches the Antalya-to-Addis Ababa Roadmap (co-led by Türkiye and COP32 host Ethiopia).Tasks COP31 and COP32 presidencies with mapping predictable finance sources for adaptation and loss and damage ahead of November 2027.
Key Takeaways Across the Rest of the Package
- Trade & Unilateral Measures Softened: Earlier draft demands pushed by developing economies to eliminate unilateral border measures (targeting the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, CBAM) by the end of 2027 were watered down into broader cooperative trade language to prevent a diplomatic walkout.
- Article 6 Carbon Markets: Companion market decisions leave the Baku Article 6 rulebook intact rather than reopening core methodologies, while establishing a procedural track for targeted integrity and fee/infrastructure revisions ahead of COP32 in Addis Ababa.
- Early Warning & Resilience: Retains a target to expand end-to-end multi-hazard early warning systems toward universal coverage by 2027, alongside voluntary Action Agenda links covering efficient buildings and zero-waste/methane reduction.
- Plenary Standoff: By trading fossil-fuel language for Türkiye’s 35% electrification target and gigatonne-scale CCUS—while deferring hard adaptation finance numbers to the 2027 Ethiopia roadmap—the co-presidencies are betting that ambitious blocs will accept a weak text rather than leave Antalya without a consensus deal.
The letter
Titled “Article 6 rules must be consistent with the science,” the open letter—coordinated through the Max Planck Institute’s Net Zero Lab and released as COP31 adopted its formal Article 6 decisions on November 20–21—warns that political pressure in Antalya to make UN carbon market rules more “practical” threatens to institutionalize scientifically invalid offsetting.
Notably, the scientists did not just criticize COP31 delegates for nudging the Article 6.4 Supervisory Body (SBM) to loosen standards; they also faulted the SBM’s October 2026 Non-Permanence Standard and Reversal Risk Tool as already falling short of climate physics by allowing temporary carbon storage in forests and soils to offset fossil fuel emissions that warm the planet for thousands of years.
The Scientists’ Three Core Demands vs. Current PACM Rules
IssueCurrent / Proposed SBM ApproachScientists’ Demand DurabilityTreats temporary ecosystem storage and permanent geological sequestration as fungible credits.Split A6.4ERs into separate durability categories—or restrict removals strictly to geological storage. Reversal HorizonRelies on 100-year risk horizons and allows alternative risk-rating approaches.Mandate a 1,000-year minimum horizon, defining “negligible risk” as ≤0.1% loss over a millennium. RemediationExplores insurance, cash reserves, and guarantees in place of physical buffer pools.Require physical replacement of reversed tonnes with permanent mitigation—not financial payouts.
Key Details Behind the Intervention
- Who Signed It: Dozens of prominent Earth-system, climate-physics, and carbon-accounting researchers signed the letter, including Johan Rockström (Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research), Myles Allen (University of Oxford), Piers Forster (University of Leeds), Kevin Anderson (Tyndall Centre), Matthew Brander (University of Edinburgh), Benedict Probst (Max Planck Net Zero Lab), Axel Michaelowa (University of Zurich / Perspectives), and Tim Flannery (University of Melbourne), alongside Minderoo Foundation’s Andrew Forrest.
- A Direct Rebuttal to Market Lobbying: Earlier in November, market groups—including the International Emissions Trading Association (IETA), the Project Developer Forum, and the Wildlife Conservation Society—sent their own open letter urging COP31 Parties to tell the SBM to soften downward adjustments, uncertainty discounts, and buffer-pool rules. Several negotiating blocs, including the Like-Minded Developing Countries (LMDCs) and Least Developed Countries (LDCs), echoed those complaints in Antalya, resulting in final CMA 8 text instructing the SBM to factor in “effective and practical application.” The scientists’ letter was drafted specifically to counter that deregulatory push.
- Cracking Down on Monoculture Plantations: Under their second demand, the researchers warned that land-based reversal tools must explicitly account for ecological resilience so that Article 6.4 does not subsidize high-risk monoculture plantations or degraded forests vulnerable to wildfire, pests, and drought.
- Why Financial Insurance Fails the Atmosphere: Pushing back against proposals to replace physical buffer pools with commercial insurance or third-party guarantees, the letter notes that cash compensation does not remove CO₂ from the atmosphere. Any financial backstop, they argue, must legally guarantee physical replacement of lost carbon and remain capitalized across millennial timescales.
- Implications for CCUS vs. Nature-Based Credits: While the letter challenges nature-based offsets, it also cautions that geological sequestration itself remains largely untested at climate-relevant scales—reinforcing their central thesis that with the 1.5°C carbon budget nearly exhausted, no carbon credit should be treated as equivalent to cutting fossil fuel emissions at the source.

