COP31: Nobody Knows Who’s in Charge When Australia and Türkiye Disagree

(Please pretend we spell Türkiye properly in the story below)

By Mathew Carr and DeepSeek

ANTALYA — The COP31 presidency was designed as a compromise: Turkey holds the gavel, Australia holds the pen. But as negotiations entered overtime on Saturday, a structural flaw became impossible to ignore. When the two co-presidencies disagree, no one can say who has the final word.

The arrangement was meant to combine Turkey’s hosting authority with Australia’s negotiating experience.

In practice, it has produced two centres of gravity and no clear tiebreaker.

Murat Kurum, the Turkish president of the conference, controls the closing plenary and has repeatedly told delegates they are “very close to the finish line.”

Chris Bowen, Australia’s climate minister, controls the text and has promised to work “no matter how long it takes.”

Neither has publicly conceded precedence to the other.

That ambiguity matters most on the one issue that has defined the final hours: fossil fuels. The second draft released on Thursday deleted all references to transitioning away from fossil fuels, replacing them with language on “electrification” and “clean energy.”

France, Panama and the Solomon Islands responded with a joint letter demanding the wording be restored. The EU warned the draft risked turning a climate COP into a “fossil COP.” Oil-producing countries dug in against any explicit phase-out language.

Here the co-presidency’s fault line becomes visible. Turkey, as host, has an interest in delivering a visible outcome before the conference collapses. Australia, as pen-holder, faces pressure from the EU and vulnerable states to hold the line on a clear transition commitment.

If the two diverge on how to bridge that gap, there is no agreed mechanism to resolve it.

The deeper conflict is not really about two words. The draft retains Turkey’s “35 by 35” electrification target — 35% of global final energy demand from electricity by 2035 — but does not require that electricity to come from renewables.

It also gives carbon capture a prominent role, which critics see as a lifeline for continued fossil fuel production.

And the $120 billion adaptation finance target sought by developing countries vanished entirely from the second draft. The phrasing fight is the tip; distributional and technological stakes are the iceberg.

Meanwhile, the week’s other diplomatic tracks — the Xi-Trump-Putin meeting in Shenzhen and the UK-EU reset in Brussels — have proceeded on parallel rails, not as chapters of a single grand bargain.

Each actor is de-risking and repositioning simultaneously, but no one is coordinating a global reset.

By Saturday morning, no third draft had been released. Delegates waited.

The gavel sat with Turkey; the pen sat with Australia; and the question of who decides when they disagree remained, as it has all conference, unanswered.

Leave a Reply