–How Managed Fictional Friction is Replacing Substantial Progress Needed to Improve the World for Ordinary People: From UN Climate Talks to Brussels to Shenzhen
Opinion By Mathew Carr
Nov. 20, 2026 — Antalya, Türkiye — The historic trilateral summit between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin yesterday in Shenzhen follows a familiar and deceptive diplomatic playbook that the European Union and China used a couple of months earlier.
The same sinister logic is playing out this week at the UN COP31 climate talks in Antalya, where major economies are declining to implement binding fossil-fuel reductions and failing to provide solid finance commitments while offering carefully hedged diplomatic language.
Just as Brussels and Beijing struck an October understanding to cap Chinese hybrid vehicle imports at 350,000 units a year rather than tumble into an all-out tariff war, yesterday’s Shenzhen “Declaration toward Peace” was definitely not a grand reconciliation.
COP31 deception one
One of the best examples of the blatant deception at COP31 was provided by Wopke Hoekstra, the chief EU climate negotiator, who said this earlier this week in front of the world’s media: “There is no future for this whole endeavour if science doesn’t underpin our actions and we are not going to deviate an inch from that approach. The world is lost if we’re going to park science.” Yet while he said that he very well knows in his heart that the EU has been deviating from the science since the UNFCCC was formed. Under science, the EU should already be at net zero in 2026 because it has already used up its fair share of the space in the atmosphere for fossil fuel emissions under the 1.5C target in the Paris climate deal and it knows it has. The biggest trade bloc should already be providing about 100 billion euros a year in climate finance to so-called developing countries by itself if science and maths were used properly to calculate a just sum. (That’s compared with the 32 billion euros per year it provided last year.) It takes some brazen nerve to say you won’t deviate an inch when you know you are already deviating several thousand miles, which is why the EU is being labelled the villain of the Türkiye talks in the absence of US President Donald Trump.
COP31 deception two
A second deception is deployed simply by choosing to debate and fight about what is not-so important. At COP31 that is the fight about the “cover decision”, which is kind of the prologue to a rule book. Instead of making the rule book tighter and binding on companies, the negotiators wrestle about the prologue. Instead of making polluters pay or putting a price on emissions that would boost government revenue, envoys, the press and environmental lobby groups debate how to best word a target to boost electrification to 35% of energy use by 2035. Even Brazil did this last year asking for new types of roadmaps when Paris already insists on country emission-cutting plans known as nationally determined contributions. COP31 isn’t a single negotiation—it’s 20+ overlapping bureaucratic tracks running simultaneously. “It’s correct” to say that the UN talks are now captured by US interests, one delegate from a big Asian nation told me. Mr Trump does not need to turn up to ruin them. He can do that from Shenzhen. Instead, countries should change the global market structure to make saving the climate more automatic, said Toshiya Kaba, a professor at Iwate Prefectural University in Japan. “There are too many talks, too many divided conversations, too many negotiations. It’s very difficult to make a good decision,” he told me in an interview. Too many negotiators focus on money rather than on effective measures that would really combat climate change, he said. The most obvious example of this is making polluters pay every time they pollute and allowing carbon trading so the most cost-effective ways to cut emissions are tackled first. This most important track at COP31 (Article 6) is effectively on the scrapheap and the fledgling markets are being starved of cash. I asked COP31 co-presidencies Türkiye and Australia for comment, and also the UNFCCC and the G77 & China negotiating block.
The tactical ceasefire playbook
(see related story from yesterday on CarrZee.org)
So these three agreements: the EU EVs; Trump, Xi and Putin’s peace; and COP31’s fake deal represent tactical ceasefires: carefully calibrated exercises in managed competition designed to lower immediate risks, deliver political optics, and buy time without resolving underlying structural conflicts that hurt ordinary folks.
Whether managing industrial overcapacity, global heating or nuclear rivalry, major powers are increasingly substituting sweeping treaties with narrow stabilization pacts that protect the status quo interests. Unsurprisingly, those same interests control the media.
In October, European officials recognized that surging Chinese hybrid exports–approaching an annualized pace of 800,000 vehicles–threatened European factories, yet a full-scale trade war would have triggered devastating retaliation.
The resulting quota contained the immediate flashpoint while leaving Europe’s massive daily trade deficit with China intact.
The Shenzhen summit operated on identical logic.
Following the expiration of the New START treaty in February 2026 and lingering U.S.–China friction over advanced semiconductor curbs and Taiwan, Washington, Beijing, and Moscow pledged to reform the United Nations and reopen dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation.
Crucially, however, the declaration produced no binding arms limits, deferred concrete institutional changes, and omitted any mention of ending the war in Ukraine.
Rather than forging genuine ideological trust, all three arrangements rely on narrow zones of mutual self-interest.
Europe and China found common ground in preserving predictable market access under strict guardrails while scheduling further consultations into 2027. In Shenzhen, the three powers converged around immediate economic and institutional insulation. At COP31, rich western nations are looking to escape accountability yet again.
With Middle Eastern energy routes strained by the Iran conflict and disruptions in the Strait of Hormuz, Trump, Xi, and Putin pledged to increase refined petroleum supplies to stabilize global energy flows. This will hurt the climate.
The deals master the art of political face-saving.
The EU–China hybrid cap allowed Brussels to claim it had halved projected imports while letting Beijing point to steady export volume.
Similarly, the Shenzhen declaration hands every leader a tailored domestic victory:
Trump claims historic statesmanship alongside a renewed U.S.–China trade truce, Xi showcases China as the indispensable convener of global power, and Putin pretends Western diplomatic isolation is simply not true.
Yet in neither case did any party surrender its core leverage.
Europe retained its broader tariff architecture, while the three superpowers kept their nuclear arsenals, sanctions, and export controls intact.
Until deeper political compromises emerge, stability rests on deterrence rather than trust.
Ultimately, the agreements illustrate a defining reality of 2026 diplomacy: when major powers cannot afford a collision—and cannot agree on peace and a safe climate—they settle for a managed truce.
*with Gemini

